Kingston Whig-Standard
(by Greg Burliuk)  

"Queen's has a hit with rollicking Pirates of Penzance"

There's a reason The Pirates of Penzance has been performed virtually non-stop since 1879: it's so much darned fun.  Let's face it, no matter how serious-minded we like to present ourselves as being, we can't help but giggle at a clever spoof.

I'm not sure if they invented it, but Gilbert and Sullivan were certainly two of its most ardent practitioners.  Like Charles Dickens, they liked to take the stuffing out of important types and they also loved to play with stereotypes.  In Pirates, they sully the image of rough-and-tough pirates, brave policemen and military brass.

Queen's Musical Theatre's production of Pirates takes this inspired silliness to new levels, which, combined with a strong singing ensemble, makes for a delightful evening.  

These pirates look fairly nasty, until you notice that one of them has a teddy bear tucked into his belt, and though they occasionally snarl, they really have impeccable manners.  The cops march out smartly but are soon trembling behind palm leaves.  And the Major-General is basically a doddering, but hilarious, old fool.

The show starts off with a bang in the opening scene, when the scurvy pirates construct their ship (complete with mast) in front of our very eyes, just like a magician showing us how a trick is done.  Director Christopher Bond's way of informing us that we're in for a magical evening. (sic)

This is a production in which all the performances are strong.  After a while, I began licking my chops when a full choral number began because I knew I would hear incredible group singing.  Not that the solos were chopped liver, but there's nothing like 30 strong young voices belting out a song. 

As the romantic leads, Tyler J. Murree and Katie Harder sang beautifully and were quite romantic, although I would like to have seen them less serious (the romantic parts were when my interest began to lag.)

I got a real kick out of Dan Dumsha's dipsy Major-General, especially in his signature song, I Am the Very Model of a Modern Major General.  As is customary, a relevant modern verse was thrown in (this one combined Queen's and computer culture quite hilariously); and for good measure, Dumsha and the chorus did a reprieve (sic) double time.

Pat Brown's Pirate King was mischievous and Brown's booming baritone was impressive.

My favorite among the leads was April Johnson as Ruth.  Her performance was sly, and her singing clear and unaffected.  However, the strength of this production is the ensemble work.  The most stirring moments always occur when the stage is crowded.  My favorite had the police trembling behind leaves while the pirates were yo-ho-ho-ing in front of them.  

This is the best QMT production I have seen in years.

 

Queen's Journal
(by Alicia Cox)  

"Arghhh!  Pirates is a success: Queen's brings Gilbert & Sullivan to life with energetic cast"

The lighthearted sounds of what many (myself included) believe to be Gilbert & Sullivan's best operetta, The Pirates of Penzance, could be heard emanating from the Grand Theatre on its opening night yesterday.  Presented by Queen's Musical Theatre, the cast proved themselves to be up ot the vocal challenges of the score, and the comedic talents of some had ample opportunity to shine.

Pirates revolves around the actions of the Pirates of Penzance, known for their mercy towards orphans, if not their ferociousness.  

Headed by the Pirate King, they sail the seas reveling in their freedom.  Frederic, a pirate apprentice bound by his sense of duty, serves them well until his twenty-first birthday, when he is free to leave with his nursery maid Ruth.  Having fulfilled his piracy duty, he can now fight against them since he actually finds their thievery despicable.  

Upon landing, Frederic happens upon the many daughters of the Major General and falls in love with the sweet Mabel.  I will not divulge the remainder of the plot, as the twists are what make the story so amusing.  Let's just say it all ends happily, as operettas are wont to do.

Now, I have praised the talents of the incredible Tyler Murree before (for his performance in Richard III), so therefore I will only say on thing about his performance as Frederic--I would like Mr. Murree's autograph before he gets famous, so I can say I knew him when.   He's that good.

The entire cast, in fact, threw themselves into the production.  From Pat Brown's swashbuckling Pirate King, to April Johnson's hilarious Ruth, to the impeccable soprano of Katie Harder as Mabel, and my personal favourite, the doddering Dan Dumsha as the Major General, the energy of the cast is what made the show so enjoyable.  You can start with a great story and a beautiful score, but if the cast doesn't gel together, it's all pointless. 

Pirates is funny (see Dan Dumsha), delightfully over the top, and a pleasure to listen to.  Surely tickets will sell quickly, so do not miss this chance to escape from the return-to-school doldrums.

 

Cast  |  Production Team  |  Director's Log  |  Photos  |  Reviews

 QMT > The Shows > 2001: The Pirates of Penzance > Reviews